Gaming news

What is an idle RPG? How the genre works and why it hooks people

An idle RPG is a role-playing game that fights its own battles and leaves the planning to you. Here is how the loop works, where it came from, and how to pick one.

By ARI GG ATO · 6 min read
A small armored adventurer walks down a glowing dungeon staircase alone while coins and upgrade icons float behind
Contents · 6

An idle RPG is a role-playing game in which your character fights, loots, and levels up automatically, in most games even while the app is closed. You don't steer the battles. You decide what to upgrade, which gear and skills to use, and when to start over for a permanent bonus. The play is in the planning, and a session can be two minutes long.

The core loop of an idle RPG

Nearly every game in the genre repeats five beats:

  1. Your character fights on its own and earns a currency.
  2. You spend the currency on stats, skills, or gear, and the fights get faster.
  3. Prices rise faster than your income, so progress slows until you hit a wall.
  4. You reset the run in exchange for a permanent bonus. Games call this prestige, ascension, or rebirth.
  5. The next run passes the old wall quickly and stalls at a new one, further in.

The wall in step three is deliberate. Anthony Pecorella of the game platform Kongregate, who has written about the math of idle games, describes the genre as a seesaw between production and costs: in a typical design, costs grow exponentially while production grows more slowly. Prestige is the release valve. He defines it as a reset of most of the game in exchange for bonuses that carry into the next run, much like a New Game Plus.

Illustration of a circular path: a tiny hero fights, collects coins, upgrades a sword, meets a wall, and steps through a portal to the start
The idle RPG loop: fight, earn, upgrade, hit a wall, reset with a permanent bonus.

Where the genre came from

The idea is older than smartphones. Progress Quest, first released in January 2002 by Eric Fredricksen, lets you roll a character and then plays the entire role-playing game by itself. Its deadpan manual promises the familiar experience without the tedious micromanagement. A 2018 study of 66 idle games calls it one of the first games designed to be played without interaction. It is still free, as a Windows download or in the browser.

Idle games went mainstream in 2013 with Cookie Clicker, a browser game about baking cookies by Julien Thiennot. It has no hero and no monsters, but it made the format popular. A year later, Playsaurus dressed the idea in fantasy with Clicker Heroes: you click monsters for gold, hire heroes who do the damage for you, and eventually ascend, trading your progress for permanent power. According to the same study, it was among the ten most played games on Steam in 2015.

Two topics get their own articles: the confusing labels, in idle vs. incremental vs. clicker games, and progress while the game is closed, in how offline progress works.

What idle RPGs look like today

The label now covers games that share the loop and little else. Here are five branches with one example each, described from their official pages.

Skill grinders. Melvor Idle, from the studio Games by Malcs and published by Jagex, left early access in November 2021. Its store page describes a RuneScape-inspired game with more than 20 skills to train, and combat is only one part of it. If that sounds right for you, see our list of games like Melvor Idle.

Idle MMOs. IdleOn by Lavaflame2 is free to play. According to its store page, you build up to 11 characters, one per class, and they keep fighting while you are gone.

Formation strategy. Idle Champions of the Forgotten Realms by Codename Entertainment is free to play and carries an official Dungeons & Dragons license. You arrange Champions into a formation, and they fight automatically, also when the game is closed.

Mobile AFK RPGs. AFK means away from keyboard. AFK Arena by Lilith Games, free with in-app purchases, has you build a lineup of heroes that battles automatically. Google Play files it under the tag Idle RPG.

Dungeon divers. Grindwalk is made by one of our teams at ARI GG ATO. A single hunter fights down through the Abyss, depth by depth, while you buy attributes, fill a skill bar, forge gear, and ascend for points in a permanent upgrade tree. It is live on Google Play, with iOS and browser versions coming soon.

Three Grindwalk screens: an automatic dungeon fight above a list of attributes, a large upgrade tree, and a Welcome Back window
A typical idle RPG layout, shown in Grindwalk from one of our teams: the fight runs by itself at the top, the decisions wait below.

Why idle RPGs hook people

Pecorella gave the short version in a 2015 talk at the Game Developers Conference, reported by Game Developer. His explanation: the numbers only ever rise, so you always feel you are moving forward. Coming back after a break pays off at once, because you can spend what piled up and jump ahead. A longer break means a bigger jump.

You don't have to be constantly playing; there's constant positive growth and feedback.

Anthony Pecorella, Kongregate, GDC 2015 (via Game Developer)

The 2018 study adds a second reason. In idle games, waiting is part of playing, and experienced players touch the game less and plan more. The pleasure moves from execution to optimization: which upgrade is the cheapest way through this wall, and is it time to reset?

A quick quality test

The same study lists a defining feature of idle games: you can set the game aside and return when you are ready, with little or no penalty. If a game punishes you for missing a day, it is working against the idea of the genre.

How to pick one

Four questions sort the field quickly.

How long does offline progress count? Some games stop counting after a set number of hours, others never do. The limit decides how often you need to check in.

What survives a reset? Read the prestige screen before your first reset. It should tell you exactly what you keep and what you lose.

How is it paid for? Melvor Idle is a paid game on Steam, and its store page says it contains no microtransactions. Clicker Heroes, IdleOn, Idle Champions, and AFK Arena are free with optional purchases. Find out which model you are getting before you invest weeks.

Where do you want to play? Browser, PC, and phone versions of a game don't always share one save. Look for cloud saves or an account if you plan to switch devices.

Idle RPG questions

Is an idle RPG the same as an AFK RPG?

In practice, yes. AFK, short for away from keyboard, is the label many mobile games use for the same idea.

Do idle RPGs play themselves completely?

A few do. Progress Quest needs you only for character creation. Most sit in between: the fighting is automatic, and the decisions about upgrades, gear, and resets are yours.

What does prestige mean in an idle RPG?

A voluntary reset. You give up most of your current run and receive a permanent bonus that makes the next run faster. Clicker Heroes calls it ascension, and Grindwalk calls it Ascend.

Do I need to be online to play an idle RPG?

It depends on the game, so check the store page. Some calculate everything on your device, others need a server connection. Grindwalk, for example, can be played without an account and offline.

Are idle RPGs free?

Many are free to play with optional purchases. Some, like Melvor Idle on Steam, are paid games.

Idle RPGIdle gamesIncremental gamesPrestigeAfk rpgGenre guide

Done reading? Try it yourself.

Every game with one account – free. Collect GG Coins and climb the ranking.

To the games

More articles

All articles